Cover of Chasing the Boogeyman by Richard Chizmar

Chasing the Boogeyman

336 pages · About 6 hours to read

Plot & Storyline 9/10
Characters 8.5/10
Dialogue / Writing Style 9/10

Before you read

Genre Crime, Horror, Thriller

Spice 0/5

Gore 1/5

Pace Medium

Mood Dark · Tense · Mysterious · Creepy

Content warnings (2) tap to show
  • Violence
  • Graphic gore

My Score

Book Score9out of 10
Read it? Rate it yourself

My Review

Chasing the Boogeyman is a fictional serial-killer story written to feel like a true-crime memoir. Richard Chizmar puts a version of himself into the story, returning to his hometown of Edgewood, Maryland, just as teenage girls begin disappearing and turning up murdered. The town slowly becomes consumed by fear, suspicion, and the feeling that the killer could be someone everyone already knows.

What makes the book stand out is how convincing the format is. The photographs, small-town details, and first-person narration make it feel like you are reading about a real case, even though the murders themselves are fictional. It is creepy without relying on nonstop violence, and the slow build of paranoia gives the story a lot of its tension.

The Goods

  • Very convincing true-crime style
  • Strong small-town atmosphere
  • Creepy without overdoing the gore
  • The photographs add a lot of realism
  • Good slow-building suspense

The Bads

  • The beginning takes a little time
  • Some readers may guess the killer early
  • Not as action-heavy as a typical thriller
  • A few sections focus heavily on town history
  • The true-crime format may not work for everyone

My Recommendation

This is a great choice for readers who like serial-killer stories, true crime, and horror that feels disturbingly real. The fake memoir style is the biggest reason the book works so well, because it constantly makes you forget that the case is fictional. If you enjoy slow-building suspense, small-town paranoia, and mysteries that focus more on atmosphere and investigation than nonstop action, Chasing the Boogeyman is definitely worth reading.

Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens

In the summer of 1988, a young Richard Chizmar returns to Edgewood, Maryland, as teenage girls in the town are murdered, and the book presents the fictional case like a true-crime account with photographs and police details. No suspect is identified at the time. Years later a detective working the cold case makes a connection, and Joshua Gallagher is caught through DNA evidence. In September 2019 journalist Carly Albright tells Chizmar the Boogeyman has been caught and will speak only to him. The book ends with Chizmar's interview of Gallagher, who explains some things but refuses to answer questions about clues such as the hopscotch grid and the pennies.

Find this book at these locations

To buy

To listen

E-books

More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph

If you liked Chasing the Boogeyman, try…

  1. Cover of Sanctum by Bobby Adair8.5/10 Sanctum Bobby Adair
  2. Cover of Destroyer by Bobby Adair8/10 Destroyer Bobby Adair
  3. Cover of Dark Roads by Chevy Stevens8.5/10 Dark Roads Chevy Stevens
  4. Cover of Paradise-1 by David Wellington8/10 Paradise-1 David Wellington