Cover of The Next Civil War by Stephen Marche

The Next Civil War

256 pages · About 5 hours to read

Content & Ideas 8/10
Insight & Takeaways 8.5/10
Writing & Clarity 8/10

Before you read

Genre Non-Fiction

Pace Medium

Mood Dark · Tense · Reflective · Informative · Challenging

Content warnings (3) tap to show
  • Violence
  • Racism
  • War

My Score

Book Score8out of 10
Read it? Rate it yourself

My Review

The Next Civil War looks at what could happen if the political divisions in the United States eventually turn into widespread violence or even the breakup of the country. Stephen Marche builds the book around five possible scenarios, including a standoff between militias and the federal government, the assassination of a president, a hurricane destroying much of New York City, a major domestic terrorist attack, and eventually states separating into different countries. He backs these scenarios with research and interviews with nearly 200 people, including military experts, political scientists, law enforcement officials, historians, and people involved with extremist movements.

I thought the idea was really interesting because Marche doesn't imagine another Civil War with two armies lining up against each other. He looks at something much messier, with terrorism, militias, political violence, climate disasters, and people slowly losing trust in the government. Some parts feel frighteningly believable, while others feel like he's pushing the worst possible outcome a little too hard. That's probably my biggest issue with it. The research is strong, but sometimes the book moves from "this could happen" to almost "this will happen." Still, it's a very interesting look at how a country can become unstable long before anyone officially calls it a civil war.

The Goods

  • Very interesting look at how a modern civil war could happen
  • Backed by a lot of interviews and research
  • The five scenarios make complicated ideas easier to understand
  • Doesn't assume another civil war would look like the one in the 1860s
  • Raises some uncomfortable but interesting questions about political division

The Bads

  • Sometimes treats possible outcomes like they're almost inevitable
  • The scenarios can feel more dramatic than the evidence supports
  • Some ideas are repeated throughout the book
  • There isn't nearly as much focus on solutions as there is on collapse
  • A few of the predictions feel more like speculation than analysis

My Recommendation

This is a good fit if you like political nonfiction but also enjoy books that use imagined situations to explain what could happen in the future. I liked that Marche talks to military experts, historians, political scientists, law enforcement, and even extremists instead of just giving his own opinion. I wouldn't read it as a prediction that America is definitely going to have another civil war. It's better as a look at the warning signs and the different ways political violence could grow if things went badly. If you like books about polarization, government breakdown, political violence, and how countries fall apart, there's a lot here to think about.

Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens

Marche builds the book around five possible ways the United States could fall apart. The first begins when a rural sheriff refuses a federal order over an unsafe bridge, attracting armed militias and eventually leading to a deadly confrontation with the military. Another imagines a president being assassinated by a radicalized young man, with the country splitting between people who mourn the president and people who celebrate the killing. A third scenario has a massive hurricane devastating New York after years of drought and economic problems, creating millions of refugees and putting enormous pressure on the government. Marche then imagines a dirty bomb attack in Washington that leads to more terrorism, government crackdowns, suspended rights, and an ongoing cycle of insurgency and retaliation. His final scenario is less about fighting and more about the United States breaking apart. Marche suggests California and Texas could become independent countries, the South could separate, and the remaining states could form another nation. He finishes by arguing that none of these outcomes are guaranteed, but that the political hatred, distrust, inequality, climate pressures, and willingness to accept violence make them possible unless the country finds a way to reduce those divisions.

Find this book at these locations

To buy

To listen

E-books

More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph

If you liked The Next Civil War, try…

  1. Cover of A New Earth by Eckhart Tolle9/10 A New Earth Eckhart Tolle
  2. Cover of A Family Secret by Maureen Wood8.5/10 A Family Secret Maureen Wood
  3. Cover of The Let Them Theory by Mel Robbins8/10 The Let Them Theory Mel Robbins
  4. Cover of The I-5 Killer by Ann Rule8.5/10 The I-5 Killer Ann Rule