Cover of The I-5 Killer by Ann Rule

The I-5 Killer

304 pages · About 6 hours to read

Content & Ideas 8.5/10
Insight & Takeaways 8/10
Writing & Clarity 8.5/10

Before you read

Genre True Crime, Non-Fiction

Pace Fast

Mood Dark · Emotional · Tense · Sad · Reflective · Informative · Challenging

Content warnings (5) tap to show
  • Violence
  • Graphic gore
  • Sexual assault
  • Child abuse
  • Death of a loved one

My Score

Book Score8.5out of 10
Read it? Rate it yourself

My Review

The I-5 Killer follows Randall Woodfield, a former college football star who was drafted by the Green Bay Packers before his life turned into a long pattern of exhibitionism, robbery, sexual assault, and eventually murder. Ann Rule traces how his crimes escalated and how attacks along the Interstate 5 corridor in Oregon, Washington, and California gradually began looking like the work of the same man. What makes the story especially unsettling is how normal and successful Woodfield could appear while police were trying to connect an enormous number of violent crimes to him.

I was hooked pretty quickly because Rule spends almost as much time explaining how investigators slowly put everything together as she does describing Woodfield himself. Some of the sexual assaults are described in much more detail than I expected, and there were definitely moments where I wondered whether every detail needed to be there, but it also makes the scale of what he was doing impossible to minimize. The book is older, but the police work and the sheer number of crimes they were trying to connect still make it a really disturbing true-crime read.

Published byPenguin Random House Canada

The Goods

  • Rule keeps the investigation easy to follow
  • The escalation of Woodfield's crimes is genuinely disturbing
  • Strong look at how separate police departments connected cases
  • The surviving victims aren't forgotten
  • Moves surprisingly quickly for an older true-crime book

The Bads

  • Some assault descriptions are extremely graphic
  • The amount of sexual violence can be exhausting
  • Certain sections repeat similar crimes and patterns
  • Parts of the writing feel dated
  • Some details can feel more intrusive than necessary

My Recommendation

This is a strong one if you like Ann Rule and true crime that spends a lot of time on both the offender and the investigation that finally stopped him. I found the sheer number of attacks almost harder to process than the murders themselves, especially because Woodfield kept moving between different cities and jurisdictions. It's definitely not an easy read because Rule goes into considerable detail about rape and sexual assault, but if you like older investigative true crime and cases where police have to recognize a pattern across dozens of crimes, The I-5 Killer is worth reading.

Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens

Randall Woodfield progresses from exhibitionism and armed robbery into a long series of sexual assaults and murders committed largely along the Interstate 5 corridor. Investigators eventually connect him to the January 1981 attack on Shari Hull and Beth Wilmot, two young women he sexually assaults before shooting both in the head; Hull dies, but Wilmot survives and later helps identify him. Police arrest Woodfield in March 1981, and physical evidence and eyewitness testimony help convict him of Hull's murder and Wilmot's attempted murder, resulting in a life sentence plus 90 years, with another 35 years later added for a separate sexual assault. Rule ends with Woodfield imprisoned while authorities suspect him in many additional crimes they cannot prove. In the decades after the book was first published, DNA evidence goes on to link him to additional murders, confirming that the number of victims connected to him was even larger than prosecutors were able to establish at his original trial.

Find this book at these locations

To buy

To listen

E-books

More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph

If you liked The I-5 Killer, try…

  1. Cover of Gomorrah by Roberto Saviano8/10 Gomorrah Roberto Saviano
  2. Cover of The Psychopath Whisperer by Kent A. Kiehl8.5/10 The Psychopath Whisperer Kent A. Kiehl
  3. Cover of The Devil's Butcher Shop by Roger Morris8.5/10 The Devil's Butcher Shop Roger Morris
  4. Cover of Green River, Running Red by Ann Rule8/10 Green River, Running Red Ann Rule