Cover of The Devil's Butcher Shop by Roger Morris

The Devil's Butcher Shop

268 pages · About 5 hours to read

Content & Ideas 8.5/10
Insight & Takeaways 8.5/10
Writing & Clarity 8/10

Before you read

Genre True Crime, Non-Fiction

Pace Medium

Mood Dark · Emotional · Tense · Sad · Reflective · Informative · Challenging

Content warnings (5) tap to show
  • Violence
  • Graphic gore
  • Sexual assault
  • Torture
  • Racism

My Score

Book Score8.5out of 10
Read it? Rate it yourself

My Review

The Devil’s Butcher Shop looks at the 1980 uprising at the New Mexico State Penitentiary, where years of overcrowding, terrible conditions, corruption, and ignored warnings finally exploded into one of the most violent prison riots in U.S. history. Roger Morris spends a lot of time showing what led up to those thirty-six hours instead of treating the riot like it just happened out of nowhere.

I knew this was going to be brutal, but I wasn’t really prepared for how graphic some of the accounts would be. The violence is horrific, especially once inmates start targeting informants and people in protective custody, but what stuck with me even more was how avoidable so much of it seems when you look at the conditions beforehand. It’s heavy, detailed, and definitely not an easy read, but the amount of documentation makes it hard to dismiss what went wrong.

Published byOpen Road Media

The Goods

  • Extremely well researched
  • Strong look at what caused the riot
  • Doesn’t ignore the failures before the violence
  • Very detailed firsthand accounts
  • The human cost comes through clearly

The Bads

  • Some sections are very hard to read
  • The detail can get overwhelming
  • A lot of names and officials to keep track of
  • Certain sections feel dense
  • The violence is relentless once the riot begins

My Recommendation

This is a strong fit if you like true crime, prison history, and investigative nonfiction that digs into why something happened instead of only describing the violence afterward. What worked for me was how Morris connected the riot to years of overcrowding, corruption, bad management, and warnings that apparently went nowhere. If you can handle extremely graphic material and you want a detailed look at how a prison system can fail badly enough to end in disaster, The Devil’s Butcher Shop is a seriously memorable read.

Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens

The book builds toward the February 1980 riot at the New Mexico State Penitentiary, where inmates overpower guards, take control of the prison, and hold officers hostage while the facility collapses into complete violence. Confidential files are found, informants and prisoners in protective custody are singled out, and dozens of inmates are tortured, mutilated, or killed before the riot finally burns itself out roughly thirty-six hours later. Thirty-three prisoners die and more than two hundred are injured, while the surviving guards are eventually freed. Morris’s bigger point is that the riot wasn’t some sudden, unpredictable explosion — overcrowding, poor conditions, corruption, understaffing, drugs, and repeated warnings had been building for years, and a lot of the tragedy could’ve been prevented long before the first guard was taken hostage.

Find this book at these locations

To buy

E-books

More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph

If you liked The Devil's Butcher Shop, try…

  1. Cover of Waiting to Be Heard by Amanda Knox8/10 Waiting to Be Heard Amanda Knox
  2. Cover of The Evil Within by Darren Galsworthy8.5/10 The Evil Within Darren Galsworthy
  3. Cover of Green River, Running Red by Ann Rule8/10 Green River, Running Red Ann Rule
  4. Cover of Gomorrah by Roberto Saviano8/10 Gomorrah Roberto Saviano