
The Evil Within
Before you read
Genre True Crime, Non-Fiction, Memoir & Biography
Pace Medium
Mood Dark · Emotional · Tense · Sad · Reflective · Informative · Challenging
Content warnings (4) tap to show
- Violence
- Child abuse
- Death of a loved one
- Kidnapping
My Score
My Review
The Evil Within is Darren Galsworthy’s account of the murder of his sixteen-year-old daughter, Becky Watts, and what happened to their family after they learned the person responsible was her own stepbrother, Nathan Matthews. Darren writes about Becky’s life before the crime, the complicated family relationships around her, the days she was missing, and then the awful moment the investigation turned into something far worse than anyone had imagined.
I knew this was going to be heartbreaking, but I wasn’t prepared for how personal it would feel coming directly from Becky’s dad. The details of what happened to her are horrible, but what got to me even more was reading about a family trying to understand how someone they’d trusted could do something like this. Some parts are repetitive, but that almost felt understandable considering how much grief and disbelief Darren was trying to put into words. It’s one of those true-crime books where the victim and her family stay at the centre instead of the killer becoming the whole story.
The Goods
- Very personal firsthand perspective
- Keeps Becky at the centre of the story
- Strong emotional impact
- Gives a clear picture of the family fallout
- The trial and investigation are easy to follow
The Bads
- Some parts feel repetitive
- Extremely difficult subject matter
- The trial details can get heavy
- A few sections are emotionally exhausting
- Definitely not an easy true-crime read
My Recommendation
This is a strong fit if you like true crime that focuses on the victim and the family left behind rather than turning the murderer into the most interesting person in the room. What worked for me was how personal Darren’s perspective made everything, especially because Nathan wasn’t some stranger — he was someone Darren had helped raise and trusted as part of the family. If you can handle a very upsetting case involving the murder and dismemberment of a teenage girl, The Evil Within is heartbreaking, disturbing, and really hard to forget.
Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens
Becky Watts disappears from her Bristol home in February 2015, and what first looks like a missing-person case turns into a murder investigation when police discover that her stepbrother Nathan Matthews and his girlfriend, Shauna Hoare, had planned to kidnap her as part of a sexually motivated fantasy. Nathan attacks and suffocates Becky during the kidnapping attempt, then later dismembers her body and hides the remains in bags and boxes in a friend's shed nearby. Matthews is eventually convicted of murder and receives life in prison with a minimum term of 33 years, while Hoare is acquitted of murder but convicted of manslaughter and conspiracy to kidnap and receives a 17-year sentence. Darren’s account ends up being less about solving a mystery and more about a father learning exactly what happened to his daughter, sitting through the trial, and trying to live with the fact that the person responsible was someone he had once treated like his own son.
Find this book at these locations
To buy
- Amazon paperback or hardcover
- Bookshop.org from a local shop
E-books
- Kindle
- Google Play Books
- Libby free from your library
More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph



