Cover of The Black Farm by Elias Witherow

The Black Farm

Book 1 of The Black Farm · see reading order

Plot & Storyline 9/10
Characters 8/10
Dialogue / Writing Style 7/10

Before you read

Genre Splatterpunk, Extreme Horror

Spice 1/5

Gore 4/5

Pace Fast

Mood Dark · Emotional · Tense · Mysterious · Adventurous · Creepy · Sad · Challenging

Content warnings (11) tap to show
  • Violence
  • Graphic gore
  • Sexual assault
  • Self-harm
  • Suicide
  • Death of a loved one
  • Torture
  • Kidnapping
  • Drug or alcohol abuse
  • Mental illness
  • Pregnancy loss

My Score

Book Score8out of 10
Read it? Rate it yourself

My Review

After losing a child and a bunch of other awful stuff, Nick and Jess decide to end their lives together. Nick wakes up somewhere that isn't peaceful at all. It's a horrible place full of monsters and people who have lost their minds, and he can't find Jess. So he picks up an axe and goes looking for her, knowing she's stuck somewhere in this nightmare too.

Honestly I couldn't put this down. The world is one of the creepiest I've read, and I loved learning how this place works as Nick figures it out. It's brutal though, like really brutal, and some scenes were hard to get through. The writing is pretty rough in places, with a lot of all caps and over the top lines, but the story and the love between Nick and Jess kept me hooked.

Note: This review and rating are based specifically on the splatterpunk/extreme horror genre. The score reflects how well the book works within that genre and delivers what fans of extreme horror are looking for, rather than comparing it directly to mainstream fiction or other genres.

Published byElias Witherow

The Goods

  • One of the creepiest settings I've read
  • Keeps moving fast, hard to put down
  • Nick will do anything for Jess
  • The monsters are wild and memorable
  • Darker and sadder than I expected

The Bads

  • Writing feels rough and a bit amateur
  • Too many all caps and exclamation marks
  • The middle feels like a long fetch quest
  • Some of the brutality feels like too much
  • A few silly moments near the end

My Recommendation

I'd only recommend this one if you already read extreme horror and know you can handle really dark stuff. If you like twisted afterlife stories, creepy monsters and a love story buried under all the misery, you'll probably fly through it. Check the warnings first though, because there's a lot here that could be really upsetting, especially the suicide and sexual violence.

Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens

The Black Farm is where people who die by suicide end up, a place between Heaven and Hell run by a giant monster called the Pig, and anyone who dies there just gets reborn there to suffer all over again. Nick finally gets Jess back, kills a holy being and eats it, and forces the Pig to eat holy flesh too, which throws the whole balance of the Farm off. Since the Pig can't keep them anymore, Nick and Jess get sent back to the living world. They get married and have a baby, but they're still haunted by the Farm, and it's hinted that Nick will have to pay for what he did.

Find this book at these locations

To buy

To listen

More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph

If you liked The Black Farm, try…

  1. Cover of Dead Inside by Chandler Morrison8/10 Dead Inside Chandler Morrison
  2. Cover of The Woods Are Dark by Richard Laymon7/10 The Woods Are Dark Richard Laymon
  3. Cover of Sick B*stards by Matt Shaw7.5/10 Sick B*stards Matt Shaw
  4. Cover of This Is for Jazz by Zach Graham8/10ARC This Is for Jazz Zach Graham