
Stolen Tongues
Before you read
Genre Horror, Mystery, Thriller
Spice 0/5
Gore 2/5
Pace Medium
Mood Dark · Emotional · Tense · Mysterious · Creepy · Sad
Content warnings (4) tap to show
- Violence
- Graphic gore
- Death of a loved one
- Pregnancy loss
My Score
My Review
Felix and Faye head to a remote mountain cabin to celebrate their engagement and almost immediately realize something is seriously wrong. Strange voices start coming from the woods, something keeps appearing outside the cabin, and Faye begins talking in her sleep to a presence that seems to know far too much about her. Even after they leave the mountain, whatever found them there doesn’t stay behind.
I loved the feeling that something wasn’t quite right, even when I couldn’t explain why. The first part at the cabin was easily the creepiest for me, because so much of the fear comes from voices, shadows, and not really knowing what’s outside. The middle slows down and gets a little repetitive once they’re back home, but the Impostor is genuinely unsettling, and the mystery around Faye’s past kept me wanting answers.
The Goods
- The opening at the cabin is really creepy.
- The supernatural atmosphere is strong.
- The Impostor is genuinely unsettling.
- The sleepwalking and mimicry work really well.
- The mystery around Faye’s past keeps building.
The Bads
- The middle drags a little.
- Some of the scares start feeling repetitive.
- Felix can make frustrating choices.
- The mythology gets a bit messy.
- The strongest horror is front-loaded.
My Recommendation
This is a good pick if you like supernatural horror that relies more on atmosphere, strange voices, things outside the window, and that awful feeling that something is watching you. I thought the cabin section was especially effective, and there were moments when I didn’t want to turn the page but couldn’t stop myself. If you enjoy possession-style horror, creepy folklore, sleepwalking, and entities that imitate people instead of just jumping out and attacking them, this one has some really effective moments.
Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens
Felix and Faye eventually learn that the creature stalking them is an entity known as the Impostor, which mimics voices and people and has been connected to the mountain for years. The real reason it’s attached to Faye goes back to childhood: her mother had a stillborn baby named Christopher, who would’ve been the fifth person in their family, and Faye buried the memory so deeply that she completely forgot he existed. The Impostor keeps demanding to know what five means because it’s trying to uncover the one memory Faye can’t give it. Along the way it kills Tíwé and the other people who try to help them, and uses pieces of its victims to imitate them. Once Faye finally remembers Christopher and accepts what happened, she confronts the Impostor directly, tells it the truth about number five, and orders it to leave. That breaks the hold it had over her. Aside from one later night when it only sings, the creature stays away.
Find this book at these locations
To buy
- Amazon paperback or hardcover
To listen
- Audible free sample
E-books
- Kindle
- Google Play Books
- Libby free from your library
More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph



