Cover of Girl Island by Kate Castle

Girl Island

374 pages · About 7 hours to read

Plot & Storyline 8.5/10
Characters 8.5/10
Dialogue / Writing Style 8/10

Before you read

Genre Young Adult, Thriller, Romance, LGBTQ

Spice 1/5

Gore 0/5

Pace Fast

Mood Emotional · Tense · Adventurous · Romantic

Content warnings (1) tap to show
  • Death of a loved one

My Score

Book Score8.5out of 10
Read it? Rate it yourself

My Review

Girl Island follows six teenage girls who survive a plane crash and end up stranded on a deserted island. Seventeen-year-old Ellery is already dealing with bullying, class differences, and the fallout from an old friendship, and being trapped with the same girls she has problems with makes survival even more complicated.

The book mixes a stranded-survival story with a strong coming-of-age angle, and there is also a central lesbian romance that gives the story more heart. A lot of the tension comes from the girls’ personalities, secrets, and old grudges, so the island is dangerous, but the real pressure often comes from the group itself.

Published byKate Castle

The Goods

  • Strong survival setup
  • Good lesbian romance
  • Interesting group dynamics
  • Ellery is easy to root for
  • Good mix of tension and emotion

The Bads

  • Some characters feel stereotyped at first
  • A few conflicts are predictable
  • The survival side could be more detailed
  • Certain character turns happen quickly
  • The teen drama may not work for everyone

My Recommendation

This is a good choice for readers who like lesbian YA, survival stories, and books where a group of very different characters are forced to depend on each other. The romance gives the story a softer emotional side, while the bullying, old friendships, and personality clashes keep plenty of tension going even when the girls are not dealing with the island itself. If you enjoy LGBTQ+ coming-of-age stories with adventure, danger, and a strong found-family feel, Girl Island is a fun and easy book to get into.

Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens

Six teenage girls survive a plane crash and are stranded together on an island. Survival does not erase the class divisions, bullying, and broken friendship they brought from school.

Find this book at these locations

To buy

E-books

More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph

If you liked Girl Island, try…

  1. Cover of Lies My Girlfriend Told Me by Julie Anne Peters8/10 Lies My Girlfriend Told Me Julie Anne Peters
  2. Cover of Keeping You a Secret by Julie Anne Peters8/10 Keeping You a Secret Julie Anne Peters
  3. Cover of Huntress by Malinda Lo8.5/10 Huntress Malinda Lo
  4. Cover of Crier's War by Nina Varela8.5/10 Crier's War Nina Varela