
We Were Liars
Before you read
Genre Young Adult, Mystery, Thriller
Spice 0/5
Gore 0/5
Pace Fast
Mood Dark · Emotional · Tense · Mysterious · Romantic · Sad · Reflective
Content warnings (6) tap to show
- Violence
- Death of a loved one
- Animal death
- Drug or alcohol abuse
- Mental illness
- Racism
My Score
My Review
We Were Liars follows Cadence Sinclair, a teenager from a wealthy family that spends every summer on their private island. She is especially close with her cousins Johnny and Mirren and their friend Gat, and together they call themselves the Liars. After a terrible accident leaves Cadence with memory loss and painful migraines, she returns to the island trying to figure out what happened during the summer she can no longer remember.
I really liked the mystery because you know something is wrong almost from the beginning, but you are never completely sure what Cadence has forgotten. The family is full of secrets, money problems, jealousy, and people pretending everything is perfect when it clearly isn't. The writing is simple but a little different, and it took me a few chapters to get used to it. The ending is easily the strongest part and completely changes how you look at the rest of the book.
The Goods
- Really good mystery
- Very easy to keep reading
- Strong summer island setting
- Lots of family secrets
- The ending really hits
The Bads
- The writing style takes some getting used to
- Some characters are hard to like
- The family drama can feel repetitive
- A few clues make the twist easier to guess
- The characters could have been developed more
My Recommendation
This is a great fit if you like short psychological thrillers with family secrets and a big ending twist. I liked the private island setting and slowly trying to figure out what Cadence couldn't remember. There is also some romance, but the mystery and family problems are much more important. If you like books where the ending makes you rethink everything you just read, this is definitely worth trying.
Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens
Cadence eventually remembers that she and the other Liars deliberately set fire to the family's main house because they believed destroying it would stop the adults from fighting over money and inheritance. The plan goes horribly wrong, and Johnny, Mirren, Gat, and the family's dogs all die in the fire while Cadence survives. The biggest twist is that the three Liars she has been spending time with since returning to the island were never really there. They were ghosts, or part of Cadence finally facing what happened. Once she remembers the truth, she says goodbye to them and is left to live with the guilt while trying to move forward with her life.
Find this book at these locations
To buy
- Amazon paperback or hardcover
- Bookshop.org from a local shop
To listen
- Audible free sample
E-books
- Kindle
- Google Play Books
- Libby free from your library
More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph



