Cover of Then She Was Gone by Lisa Jewell

Then She Was Gone

368 pages · About 7 hours to read

Plot & Storyline 8.5/10
Characters 8/10
Dialogue / Writing Style 8.5/10

Before you read

Genre Psychological Thriller, Mystery

Spice 1/5

Gore 0/5

Pace Fast

Mood Dark · Emotional · Hopeful · Tense · Mysterious · Romantic · Creepy · Sad · Reflective

Content warnings (10) tap to show
  • Violence
  • Sexual assault
  • Child abuse
  • Suicide
  • Death of a loved one
  • Animal death
  • Torture
  • Kidnapping
  • Mental illness
  • Pregnancy loss

My Score

Book Score8.5out of 10
Read it? Rate it yourself

My Review

Then She Was Gone follows Laurel, whose fifteen year old daughter Ellie disappeared without a trace ten years earlier. The loss destroyed her family and left Laurel unable to really move on. When she meets a charming man named Floyd, she finally starts feeling happy again. But then she meets his young daughter Poppy, who looks so much like Ellie that Laurel can't stop wondering if there is more to the connection.

I really liked how this slowly builds the mystery while also showing what Ellie's disappearance did to the whole family. You start getting little pieces of the past, and it becomes harder to know who to trust. Some of the twists are easier to guess than others, but the full story is much darker than I expected. It is creepy, emotional, and very easy to keep reading.

The Goods

  • Really strong mystery from the beginning
  • Easy to keep reading
  • Good mix of family drama and suspense
  • Several disturbing twists
  • The emotional side of the story works really well

The Bads

  • Some twists are fairly easy to guess
  • A few parts depend on unlikely coincidences
  • Some characters make frustrating choices
  • The middle slows down a little
  • The full explanation gets very dark

My Recommendation

This is a great fit if you like psychological thrillers about missing people, family secrets, and old mysteries coming back years later. I liked that it isn't only about finding out what happened to Ellie. A lot of the story is also about grief and what losing someone can do to a family. It gets much darker as the truth comes out, but if you like emotional thrillers with some creepy twists, this is definitely worth reading.

Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens

Ellie did not run away. Her former tutor kidnapped her and kept her hidden for years, eventually forcing her to have a baby. Ellie dies while still being held captive, and that baby grows up to be Poppy, which explains why she looks so much like her. Laurel eventually learns the truth through Floyd, who had discovered what happened after Poppy was born and killed the woman responsible. Floyd later takes his own life and leaves Poppy with Laurel. By the end, Laurel finally knows what happened to Ellie and begins rebuilding her relationship with her family while becoming part of Poppy's life.

Find this book at these locations

To buy

To listen

E-books

More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph

If you liked Then She Was Gone, try…

  1. Cover of Only Survivors by Megan Miranda7.5/10 Only Survivors Megan Miranda
  2. Cover of Those Girls by Chevy Stevens8.5/10 Those Girls Chevy Stevens
  3. Cover of Missing Molly by Natalie Barelli8/10 Missing Molly Natalie Barelli
  4. Cover of The Girl Who Was Taken by Charlie Donlea8.5/10 The Girl Who Was Taken Charlie Donlea