Cover of The Girl Who Was Taken by Charlie Donlea

The Girl Who Was Taken

340 pages · About 6 hours to read

Plot & Storyline 8.5/10
Characters 8.5/10
Dialogue / Writing Style 8/10

Before you read

Genre Psychological Thriller, Mystery, Crime

Spice 0/5

Gore 3/5

Pace Medium

Mood Dark · Emotional · Tense · Mysterious · Sad

Content warnings (5) tap to show
  • Violence
  • Sexual assault
  • Death of a loved one
  • Torture
  • Kidnapping

My Score

Book Score8.5out of 10
Read it? Rate it yourself

My Review

The Girl Who Was Taken follows two disappearances from the same night. Megan McDonald escapes after being held captive for two weeks, while Nicole Cutty never comes home. A year later, Nicole’s older sister Livia is training as a forensic pathologist when a body on her autopsy table gives her the first real connection to what happened to Nicole. At the same time, Megan’s memories of her captivity are starting to come back, and the version of events everyone thinks they understand begins falling apart.

I was hooked pretty early because there are enough possible suspects that I kept second-guessing everyone. I also really liked the forensic pathology side of the story because the autopsies aren’t just thrown in for shock—they actually move the investigation forward. There are a lot of timelines and characters to keep straight, and a few sections get bogged down in the medical details, but once everything starts connecting, it moves quickly. The final reveal was genuinely disturbing, and I liked that the clues were sitting there without making the answer obvious.

Published byPenguin Random House Canada

The Goods

  • The mystery keeps you guessing
  • Strong forensic pathology angle
  • Several believable suspects
  • The timelines eventually connect really well
  • The main reveal is genuinely unsettling

The Bads

  • There are a lot of characters to track
  • Some autopsy sections get very detailed
  • The middle slows down in places
  • A few twists stretch believability
  • The very last ending is frustratingly open

My Recommendation

This is a really good fit if you like missing-person thrillers, forensic investigations, and mysteries where you're constantly changing your mind about who you trust. The medical examiner angle made it stand out for me because Livia is uncovering the mystery through actual physical evidence while Megan is trying to recover memories she can't completely trust. It gets considerably darker than a standard missing-girl mystery, especially once the truth about the kidnappings comes out, but if you like thrillers with a big late reveal and plenty of misdirection, this one works really well.

Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens

Nicole Cutty and Megan McDonald disappear on the same night, but the truth is that Nicole had become involved with her boyfriend Casey and his disturbing Capture Club, which began with staged kidnappings before Casey started abducting women for real. Casey is secretly supplying victims to another man, and when a staged kidnapping of Megan that Nicole planned turns into a real abduction, he has no idea the client is Megan’s own father, police chief Terry McDonald. Nicole realizes what Casey is doing and tries to escape, eventually trusting a police officer for help—only to discover that officer is Terry. Terry kills Casey, keeps Megan captive for two weeks to hide what happened, and then deliberately releases her while continuing to hold Nicole and other women. More than a year later, Megan’s returning memories lead her and Livia to the abandoned house where Terry kept his victims, and they rescue another captive named Elizabeth, who says she had been talking to a prisoner named Nicole. Terry arrives intending to kill everyone and destroy the evidence, but Livia fights him and badly burns him. He eventually confesses and claims he killed Nicole before investigators arrived and buried her in the forest. Six months later, Livia is called to examine a young woman’s body found in the area where Terry claimed he buried Nicole, but the book ends just before the body is identified, leaving Nicole’s final identification deliberately unresolved.

Find this book at these locations

To buy

To listen

E-books

More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph

If you liked The Girl Who Was Taken, try…

  1. Cover of The Silent Ones by K.L. Slater8/10 The Silent Ones K.L. Slater
  2. Cover of Those Girls by Chevy Stevens8.5/10 Those Girls Chevy Stevens
  3. Cover of Missing Molly by Natalie Barelli8/10 Missing Molly Natalie Barelli
  4. Cover of Only Survivors by Megan Miranda7.5/10 Only Survivors Megan Miranda