Cover of The look-alike by Erica Spindler

The look-alike

320 pages · About 6 hours to read

Plot & Storyline 8/10
Characters 7.5/10
Dialogue / Writing Style 7.5/10

Before you read

Genre Psychological Thriller, Mystery, Thriller

Spice 1/5

Gore 0/5

Pace Medium

Mood Dark · Emotional · Tense · Mysterious · Romantic

Content warnings (3) tap to show
  • Violence
  • Death of a loved one
  • Mental illness

My Score

Book Score7.5out of 10
Read it? Rate it yourself

My Review

The Look-Alike follows Sienna Scott, who returns to her Wisconsin hometown ten years after stumbling across the murdered body of college student Madison Robie. Sienna has always wondered whether Madison was killed by mistake because the two women were wearing similar coats that night, but that fear is tangled up with something even more unsettling: Sienna’s mother suffers from persecutory delusional disorder, and Sienna has spent years wondering whether she might eventually develop it too. When strange things start happening after she comes home, she can’t tell whether someone really is targeting her or whether she’s beginning to see threats that aren’t there.

I liked the way the book kept making me question Sienna without turning her mother’s mental illness into a cheap explanation for everything. There are enough suspicious people around her that I kept second-guessing who I trusted, and Jonathan showing up across the street adds another layer because he clearly knows more about the old murder than he initially admits. The romance happens a little too quickly for me and the beginning takes some time to get moving, but once the old case starts opening up again, I wanted to know whether Sienna had actually been right all along.

Published byMacmillan Publishers

The Goods

  • Good unreliable-narrator feeling without making Sienna completely unreliable
  • Plenty of believable suspects
  • The mental-health angle adds real tension
  • The old murder mystery keeps getting more complicated
  • The final killer reveal works well

The Bads

  • The beginning takes a while to build
  • The romance develops very quickly
  • Some clues and suspicions get repeated
  • A few characters feel more like red herrings than fully developed people
  • The ending ties everything up a little too neatly

My Recommendation

This is a good fit if you like psychological thrillers where the main character isn’t sure whether she can trust what she’s experiencing. I liked having the unsolved murder, Sienna’s fear of inheriting her mother’s disorder, and several suspicious people all working against each other at the same time. The romance is a bigger part of the story than I expected, so it also works well if you like romantic suspense. It isn’t the darkest or most complicated thriller out there, but it’s an easy one to keep turning pages on once the mystery gets going.

Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens

Sienna eventually learns that Jonathan, the attractive man who moved in across the street, is actually murdered student Madison Robie’s brother and came to town hoping to find out who killed his sister. Sienna initially becomes suspicious of him and several other people, while also discovering that her half-brother Brad has secretly lost money that belonged to her. The biggest break comes when Sienna finds the murder weapon hidden among belongings her mother had saved for her, making it appear that her mother might somehow be involved. The real killer is police officer Randy, who murdered Madison ten years earlier because he mistook her for Sienna and has spent years believing that he and Sienna belong together. He planted the weapon in her mother’s home and manipulated events around Sienna so that the people standing between them would be blamed or pushed away. Sienna finally realizes that the danger she feared all those years was real rather than an inherited delusion, Randy is exposed, and Sienna survives and ends up with Jonathan.

Find this book at these locations

To buy

To listen

E-books

More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph

If you liked The look-alike, try…

  1. Cover of Stolen Sisters by Louise Jensen8/10 Stolen Sisters Louise Jensen
  2. Cover of Wayward by Blake Crouch8.5/10 Wayward Blake Crouch
  3. Cover of The Housemaid by Freida McFadden8/10 The Housemaid Freida McFadden
  4. Cover of Three on the Roof by N.C. Cole8.5/10ARC Three on the Roof N.C. Cole