
Stolen Sisters
Before you read
Genre Psychological Thriller, Thriller, Mystery
Spice 1/5
Gore 0/5
Pace Medium
Mood Emotional · Tense · Mysterious · Sad · Reflective
Content warnings (6) tap to show
- Violence
- Child abuse
- Suicide
- Kidnapping
- Drug or alcohol abuse
- Mental illness
My Score
My Review
The Stolen Sisters follows Carly and her younger twin sisters, Leah and Marie, twenty years after the three of them were kidnapped as children. They survived and escaped, but none of them really left what happened behind. Carly still blames herself for not protecting them, Marie uses alcohol and drugs to bury the memories, and Leah’s OCD and anxiety have become a huge part of her adult life. As the twentieth anniversary gets closer, old fears start coming back and Leah begins receiving messages that make her think the past isn’t finished with them yet.
I kept second-guessing everyone, which made it hard to trust anything I was reading. I liked that the book wasn’t really about whether the girls survived — we already know they did — but about what that kind of trauma can do to people years later and how differently each sister carried it. A few sections dragged a little for me and there are a lot of secrets being held back, but once those secrets started coming out, I definitely wanted to know what actually happened all those years ago.
The Goods
- Strong sister dynamic
- Good use of past and present timelines
- Keeps you questioning what really happened
- The trauma feels different for each sister
- Some genuinely surprising reveals
The Bads
- The middle can drag a little
- Some secrets are held back for a long time
- A few twists feel more convenient than others
- There are a lot of viewpoints to follow
- Some of Leah’s fears get repetitive
My Recommendation
This is a good fit if you like psychological thrillers about family secrets, childhood trauma, abduction, and people realizing they may not remember the past as clearly as they thought. I liked that the sisters didn’t all react to what happened in the same way, because that made their adult lives feel much more believable. If you enjoy thrillers where the real mystery is as much about what happened years ago as what’s happening now, The Stolen Sisters is a solid read.
Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens
Twenty years earlier, thirteen-year-old Carly and eight-year-old twins Leah and Marie are abducted after leaving their garden and are held in terrible conditions at an abandoned army site before managing to escape. As adults, all three are still carrying different versions of the guilt, and the anniversary brings everything back when Leah starts receiving countdown notes, becomes convinced their abductor has returned, and Marie disappears. The story eventually reveals that the sisters haven’t all been completely honest about what happened during and after the kidnapping, while Leah also learns her husband George has been hiding his own secrets. The different lies and half-truths finally collide in a dangerous confrontation where the sisters are forced to work together again, and by the end they survive, the truth about the past finally comes out, and there’s at least some sense that they can start healing instead of living completely inside what happened to them.
Find this book at these locations
To buy
- Amazon paperback or hardcover
- Bookshop.org from a local shop
To listen
- Audible free sample
E-books
- Kindle
- Google Play Books
- Libby free from your library
More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph



