
The Dungeon Anarchist's Cookbook
Before you read
Genre Science Fiction, Dystopian
Spice 0/5
Gore 2/5
Pace Medium
Mood Dark · Emotional · Funny · Tense · Mysterious · Adventurous
Content warnings (4) tap to show
- Violence
- Graphic gore
- Drug or alcohol abuse
- War
My Score
My Review
Carl, Donut, Mongo and Katia head down to the fourth floor, the Iron Tangle, which is a giant subway system full of trains, stations and monsters that ride the lines. The floor is basically one big puzzle, and the party has to figure out how it works while crawlers keep getting stuck all over the map. Along the way Carl gets his hands on a strange book that gives him a lot more to think about than just staying alive.
This one took me a little longer to get into because the train setup is kind of confusing at first, and there's a lot of mapping and crafting. Once things start falling apart, though, it gets really good. Katia finally gets more to do, Carl starts turning into more than just a guy who blows stuff up, and the ending is huge. It's still funny, but it's darker and angrier than the first two, and I liked where it's going.
The Goods
- The ending is one of the best in the series so far
- Katia gets more time and grows a lot
- The cookbook adds a cool new layer to the story
- Carl's anger at the show feels earned
- Lots of crawlers working together for once
The Bads
- The subway setup is confusing at first
- Lots of crafting and mapping in the middle
- Some of the humour is crude and tired
- A few female characters still feel flat
- Not as fresh as the first two floors
My Recommendation
If you've made it through Books 1 and 2, you'll want to read this one, because it sets up a lot for the rest of the series. Just know the train puzzle can be hard to follow, and it takes a while before things really take off. Same warnings as before for swearing, crude jokes and bloody fights, and it's a little darker this time.
Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens
The book Carl wins is the Dungeon Anarchist's Cookbook, a secret guide written by past crawlers who tried to fight back against the dungeon, and he has to hide what it really is from the show. Hekla turns on the party and secretly tries to kill Katia, and in the fight that follows Katia ends up accidentally killing Hekla. When the floor collapses, Carl and a group of crawlers use the train portals to dump the monsters into the abyss. Carl even tricks the war god Grull, who has been summoned to kill him, into getting sent there too, then sends the Nightmare Express in after him. Carl comes out of it set on taking down the whole system, not just surviving it, and the book ends with the party at the door to the fifth floor's desert.
Next in Dungeon Crawler Carl
Book 4 The Gate of the Feral GodsBefore this: Book 2 Carl's Doomsday Scenario · The whole series in order (5 books)
Find this book at these locations
To buy
- Amazon paperback or hardcover
- Bookshop.org from a local shop
To listen
- Audible free sample
More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph



