Cover of The Consequence of Anna by Kate Birkin

The Consequence of Anna

550 pages · About 10 hours to read

Plot & Storyline 8.5/10
Characters 8.5/10
Dialogue / Writing Style 8/10

Before you read

Genre Historical Fiction, Literary Fiction

Spice 2/5

Gore 1/5

Pace Slow

Mood Dark · Emotional · Tense · Romantic · Sad · Reflective · Challenging

Content warnings (7) tap to show
  • Violence
  • Explicit sexual content
  • Domestic abuse
  • Self-harm
  • Suicide
  • Death of a loved one
  • Mental illness

My Score

Book Score8.5out of 10
Read it? Rate it yourself

My Review

The Consequence of Anna is set in 1930s Australia and centres on Anna, her husband James, and Anna’s beloved cousin Lottie. When widowed Lottie returns to the family sheep station desperately wanting a child, Anna comes up with the idea that James should give her one. What Anna sees as this incredibly generous gift turns into something she never planned for once James and Lottie develop real feelings for each other.

There was a lot more going on beneath the surface than I first realized. The love triangle is obviously a huge part of it, but the book also gets into mental illness, obsession, friendship, betrayal, family, and how one decision can completely change everyone involved. It’s a long book and there were definitely stretches where I wanted things to move a little faster, but Anna is such a complicated character that I kept wanting to see just how badly everything was going to unravel.

Published byKate Birkin

The Goods

  • Anna is a really complicated main character
  • Strong emotional family drama
  • The Australian setting adds a lot
  • The love triangle has real consequences
  • Good exploration of obsession and mental illness

The Bads

  • Very long
  • The pacing can be slow
  • Some sections feel overly detailed
  • The writing can get a little flowery
  • A few parts could've been trimmed

My Recommendation

This is a good fit if you like historical family sagas, complicated relationships, and books where one well-intentioned decision slowly turns into a complete disaster. I liked that none of the main characters came out of this feeling completely innocent, because everyone makes choices that hurt somebody else. If you enjoy emotional historical fiction about love, obsession, betrayal, mental illness, and families carrying secrets for years, The Consequence of Anna is definitely worth the longer read.

Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens

Anna grows up emotionally dependent on her cousin Lottie and later tricks James into marrying her by falsely claiming she’s pregnant. Years later, widowed Lottie comes back to Australia, and Anna decides the perfect way to make her stay forever is for James to father a child with her. James eventually agrees, but he and Lottie fall genuinely in love, begin a secret affair, and have a child together while Anna believes everything is still going according to her plan. When Anna finally discovers the affair, her already serious mental illness completely overwhelms her and she turns violent toward James, Lottie and Lottie’s baby. The story then follows the long aftermath of what she did, and how the three of them live with the consequences for decades.

Find this book at these locations

To buy

To listen

E-books

More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph

If you liked The Consequence of Anna, try…

  1. Cover of Atmosphere by Taylor Jenkins Reid9/10 Atmosphere Taylor Jenkins Reid
  2. Cover of Beneath the Same Stars by Phyllis Cole-Dai8.5/10 Beneath the Same Stars Phyllis Cole-Dai
  3. Cover of The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue by V.E. Schwab8.5/10 The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue V.E. Schwab
  4. Cover of The Galaxy, and the Ground Within by Becky Chambers8/10 The Galaxy, and the Ground Within Becky Chambers