Cover of Beneath the Same Stars by Phyllis Cole-Dai

Beneath the Same Stars

332 pages · About 6 hours to read

Plot & Storyline 8.5/10
Characters 8.5/10
Dialogue / Writing Style 8.5/10

Before you read

Genre Historical Fiction, Literary Fiction

Spice 0/5

Gore 1/5

Pace Medium

Mood Dark · Emotional · Sad · Reflective

Content warnings (3) tap to show
  • Violence
  • Kidnapping
  • War

My Score

Book Score8.5out of 10
Read it? Rate it yourself

My Review

Beneath the Same Stars is set during the U.S.-Dakota War of 1862 and follows Sarah Wakefield, a physician’s wife who is taken captive with her two young children. Their survival becomes tied to Ćaske, a Dakota man who protects them even as the conflict around them becomes more violent and unpredictable. The novel is based on real events, which gives the story a much heavier feeling than a typical piece of historical fiction.

What makes the book interesting is that it does not treat the conflict as simple or one-sided. There is a lot here about broken promises, fear, prejudice, loyalty, and the damage caused when two groups are pushed into open violence. The relationship between Sarah and Ćaske gives the story its emotional centre, while the historical setting adds a lot of tension and sadness.

Published byOne Sky Press

The Goods

  • Strong historical setting
  • Based on real events
  • Good emotional tension
  • Thoughtful look at both sides of the conflict
  • Sarah and Ćaske are memorable characters

The Bads

  • Can be slow in places
  • Some sections are emotionally heavy
  • A few characters could use more depth
  • The historical detail may feel dense
  • Not always an easy read

My Recommendation

This is a strong choice for readers who like historical fiction based on real events, especially stories that deal with conflict, survival, and complicated relationships between people on opposite sides. The U.S.-Dakota War is not covered very often in fiction, so the setting alone makes the book stand out, and the relationship between Sarah and Ćaske gives the history a very personal side. If you enjoy historical novels that are emotional, thoughtful, and willing to deal with the uglier parts of the past without making everything feel simple, this one is definitely worth reading.

Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens

During the 1862 U.S.-Dakota War, Sarah Wakefield, wife of the Upper Sioux Agency doctor John Wakefield, is taken captive with her two children and protected by the Dakota man Ćaske. After the army takes custody of the captives at Camp Release, Ćaske is tried by a U.S. military commission, the only specific charge being the murder of George Gleason, the clerk driving the Wakefields' wagon on the first day of the outbreak. Sarah, dogged by gossip that she and her captor were lovers, appears as a witness in his defense, and she becomes the only former white captive to testify on behalf of a Dakota man in more than 300 such trials. The novel is drawn from Wakefield's own account, in which Chaska was hanged at Mankato in December 1862 despite her plea to General Sibley to spare him.

Find this book at these locations

To buy

To listen

E-books

More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph

If you liked Beneath the Same Stars, try…

  1. Cover of The Consequence of Anna by Kate Birkin8.5/10 The Consequence of Anna Kate Birkin
  2. Cover of Atmosphere by Taylor Jenkins Reid9/10 Atmosphere Taylor Jenkins Reid
  3. Cover of The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue by V.E. Schwab8.5/10 The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue V.E. Schwab
  4. Cover of Fingersmith by Sarah Waters9/10 Fingersmith Sarah Waters