Cover of The Midnight Library by Matt Haig

The Midnight Library

304 pages · About 6 hours to read

Book 1 of The Midnight World · see reading order

Plot & Storyline 8.5/10
Characters 7.5/10
Dialogue / Writing Style 8/10

Before you read

Genre Contemporary Fiction, Fantasy, Literary Fiction

Spice 1/5

Gore 0/5

Pace Medium

Mood Emotional · Hopeful · Adventurous · Sad · Reflective · Inspiring

Content warnings (5) tap to show
  • Self-harm
  • Suicide
  • Death of a loved one
  • Animal death
  • Mental illness

My Score

Book Score8out of 10
Read it? Rate it yourself

My Review

The Midnight Library follows Nora Seed, a woman overwhelmed by the belief that almost every important choice she's made has been the wrong one. After reaching the point where she no longer wants to live, Nora finds herself in a mysterious library between life and death. Its endless shelves contain books representing the lives she could have lived if she'd made different choices. Guided by Mrs. Elm, the librarian from her school days, Nora can actually enter those lives—marrying the man she left, becoming an Olympic swimmer, pursuing music with her brother, becoming a glaciologist, and exploring countless other versions of herself while trying to find the one life she should have chosen.

I really liked the central idea because it's almost impossible to read this without thinking about your own decisions and all the lives you imagine might have happened if you'd chosen differently. Some of Nora's alternate lives are much more interesting than others, and after a while the pattern of trying a life and discovering why it isn't perfect becomes predictable. The message can also be a little heavy-handed; Haig doesn't exactly hide what he wants you to take away from it. But I still found the overall idea genuinely effective. The parts that worked best for me weren't really about finding the perfect alternate life at all—they were about Nora slowly realizing how unreliable regret can be. We imagine the road we didn't take without imagining any of the problems that would've been waiting there too. It's emotional, very readable, and ultimately much more hopeful than the opening suggests.

Published byPenguin Random House Canada

The Goods

  • Fantastic central "what if?" concept
  • Makes you genuinely think about your own regrets
  • Nora's different lives give the story plenty of variety
  • Very readable despite dealing with heavy subjects
  • The emotional payoff and final message work well

The Bads

  • The alternate-life structure eventually becomes repetitive
  • Some of the philosophical lessons are very obvious
  • Supporting characters aren't nearly as developed as Nora
  • Several interesting alternate lives end too quickly
  • The message can occasionally feel more explained than discovered

My Recommendation

This is a great fit if you like speculative fiction built around one big idea and enjoy books that are more interested in the emotional consequences than explaining the science behind them. I liked the way Nora's regrets gradually fall apart once she's actually forced to live the supposedly better alternatives. The book can be sentimental and occasionally feels like fiction mixed with a self-help message, so it may not work as well if you prefer subtle philosophical writing. But if you've ever wondered what your life might look like if you'd made one different decision or convinced yourself that another version of you must somehow be happier there's a lot here that will probably connect. Just be aware that suicide and depression aren't background themes; they're central to the entire story.

Spoilers Tap to show: only if you’ve read it, or don’t mind knowing what happens

Nora attempts suicide and wakes in the Midnight Library, where Mrs. Elm allows her to experience lives she could have lived by making different choices. She tries versions where she married Dan, became an Olympic swimmer, moved to Australia, became a glaciologist, and found success as a musician, but each life contains problems she never imagined. She also learns that her cat Volts would have died from an underlying condition regardless, removing one of her biggest regrets. Eventually Nora enters a life where she married Ash, became a philosophy professor, and has a daughter named Molly. It seems almost perfect, but she realizes that she never actually built those relationships and that her original life had positively affected people in ways she never noticed. When she returns to the Midnight Library, it begins collapsing because her original body is close to death. Nora finally realizes that she doesn't want a perfect alternate life—she wants the chance to continue her own. She writes "I AM ALIVE" in the book representing her original life and wakes after her overdose. Nora survives, reconnects with Joe and Izzy, recognizes that people such as Mr. Banerjee and Leo genuinely value her, and ends the story playing chess with the real Mrs. Elm, finally accepting that her unfinished life still contains countless possibilities.

Find this book at these locations

To buy

To listen

E-books

More reviews: Goodreads · The StoryGraph

If you liked The Midnight Library, try…

  1. Cover of 1Q84 by Haruki Murakami8.5/10 1Q84 Haruki Murakami
  2. Cover of A Crooked Tree by Una Mannion8.5/10 A Crooked Tree Una Mannion
  3. Cover of Half His Age by Jennette McCurdy9/10 Half His Age Jennette McCurdy
  4. Cover of In an Instant by Suzanne Redfearn8.5/10 In an Instant Suzanne Redfearn